I know I have been quite late in posting but that is for a reason, Sharif gaber final refutation to his video on Quran will be posted as promised don't worry, but I'm afraid I have some bad news for the readers
I have been diagnosed lately with a neurological condition, duo to the fact that it's a personal information I won't be sharing it or stating what it's but if it goes without treatment it could cause Coagulation of the brain.
Doctors told me I should lower my stress since it's one of the most primary causes of this
Which means I will be reducing my responses to comments significantly and probably will be rarly engaging in debates online or in comment section
The good news is that it won't stop me from posting and returning to my channel so long as I don't engage in a stressful activity such as debating or discussion
Which is the reason why some of you might noticed that I'm not engaging that much in comments.
Of course you are free to ask me any question regarding matters of theology but if you seek a dialog or discussion I'm a afraid I can't engage with you anymore duo to my health condition untill I'm medicly cleared.
In the mean time this post will remain and will be deleted when Sharif final response is posted.
Salam aleykum brother.
ReplyDeleteI have a question regarding the hadith of breastfeeding Salim. Is it true that there was physical contact during this. It is said that narrations mentioning the milk being poured into a utensil first are unreliable because they come from al-Waqidi and he is called a liar (though there are some that consider him to have some reliability like Ibn Hajr and Ibn Kathir).
I'm asking this since this filth Sam Shamoun has posted this on the following:
https://www.answering-islam.org/Responses/Menj/nursing_of_adults.htm
"Is it true that there was physical contact during this"
Deleteno, there is no irtiqam althadi (physical lips contact with the breast) at all
Notice how at the end he makes this deceptive translation
(انما يتم حلب اللبن و يشربه دون ان يري عورتها Direct contact is not necessary for nursing. In other words, the milk is collected in a cup or pot and the foster son drinks it without getting into close contact with the foster mother)
when in reality it translate to this:
milk is brought and drinked without even seeing her private part (the breast)
this filth just twisted the translation on the part that explicitly says not to see her private parts, this is not the first time i see Answering islam twist their translations
Why don't you translated the remaining of the quote? You will see the similarities. Also note Sam "The translation is not literal in every aspect"
DeletePS
ReplyDeleteSorry to hear of your medical condition. Inshallah it will get better soon. Please take good care of yourself brother.